I looked in my crystal ball (i.e., AHRI’s historic and current shipment data), and it looks like we finally put the shipment cliff in the rearview mirror. Absent more authoritarian mandates by the DOE or EPA, we can expect a decade where every year in the replacement market is better than the one before it.
During the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, another pandemic swept the boardrooms of corporate America, including HVAC. This was the pandemic of panic. In his science fiction masterpiece, "Dune," Frank Herbert wrote, “Fear is the mind-killer.” It is. Fear is pure, raw emotion. When strong emotion collides with logic and rational thought, emotion overwhelms reason every time, which explains a lot of things going on today.
At the start of COVID, the running corporate narrative in our beloved HVAC industry was pure panic-driven pessimism. The pessimists were predicting a decline of 40%. The optimists weren’t much better. They were calling for a drop of 20%. No one disputed it, except… me.
I very publicly proclaimed 2020 would be the best year in the history of the industry. It was. How could I get things so right, when everyone else was wrong?
To start, I wasn’t infected by the pandemic panic, probably because I’m an emotionally challenged, recovering engineer. I remembered working for Garry Upton at Lennox. Garry made forecasts using the AHRI data. He discovered a 15-year replacement pattern. In general, what was shipped 15 years ago would get replaced this year. He used the data to forecast the replacement market.
It wasn’t quite that straight forward. To smooth things, Upton used a three-year average of the historical data. Then, he made adjustments for the weather. Hot summers accelerate replacements taking them from next year to this year. Cool or late summers defer replacements to next year.
It’s pretty straight forward until government mucks things up. The first time this happened was the National Appliance Energy Conservation Act, which Reagan grudgingly signed after getting harangued by manufacturers. Manufacturers were sick of screwy state mandates (I’m talking about you, California). They wanted uniformity. They traded short-term ease for 40 years of government meddling.
The 10-SEER mandate resulted in a price jump that resulted in a lot of replacement deferrals and a flat industry. It was replicated when the DOE forced 13-SEER down the industry’s throat 15 years later.
The 13-SEER mandate got Wall Street excited. Conventional wisdom was equipment costs would rise 15%, resulting in 5% more sales, 15% more profit, and 15% more bonuses for everyone. JP Morgan held an analyst conference in New York to celebrate. Somehow, I got invited.
I looked at the data and noticed a 15-year spread between 10-SEER and 13-SEER. Then, I did something the manufacturers attending the conference apparently never considered. I went and talked with contractors about the impact. The equipment costs the manufacturers were looking at were only half the story. Equipment is fundamentally parts that do not become functioning products until field assembled by a contractor. The installed costs were going to jump closer to 30% than 15%.
Take the echo of the plateau in shipments from 10-SEER, add a significant price jump from 13-SEER, and I figured we would see a decline in shipments. I said so. My view became JP Morgan’s pessimistic scenario. A haughty French executive (go figure) from one manufacturer ridiculed my projection of a decline in sales. Ironically, the following year, at the same conference, he claimed his prediction of a sales decline was exactly what happened. Huh?
The impact of 13-SEER started a shipment cliff that was exasperated by the 2008 recession and is being echoed in the post-COVID data. Factor in the supply chain issues, SEER2, and A2L, and the forecast gets thrown out of whack. Nevertheless, through August, shipments are up more than 6%, even as new construction is trending down. Assuming we’ve worked through A2L, the data calls for a 10-year run of ever-increasing replacements.
It’s not a crystal ball. It’s not magic. It’s math.